Alleged N400m fraud: Court gives condition for granting Olisa Metuh’s application to travel for medicals

Justice Okon Abang of the Federal High court sitting in Maitama, Abuja, on Thursday, March 15, 2018, gave...


Justice Okon Abang of the Federal High court sitting in Maitama, Abuja, on Thursday, March 15, 2018, gave condition upon which the court would decide whether or not to grant the application by the embattled former spokesperson of the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, Olisa Metuh, to travel abroad for medical treatment.

Metuh is being prosecuted by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, EFCC, before Justice Okon Abang of the Federal High Court, sitting in Maitama, Abuja, for allegedly receiving N400million from the Office of the National Security Adviser, ONSA, in 2014 to run advocacy campaign for former President Goodluck Jonathan ahead of the 2015 general elections.

Metuh’s counsel, Emeka Etiaba, had on March 14, 2018 through an application dated and filed on February 23, 2018 sought leave of the court for the release of Metuh’s international passport to enable him travel abroad on health grounds.

Counsel to the EFCC, Silvanus Tahir, had opposed the application on the ground that similar applications have been made before and the court rejected it.

According to Tahir, “No circumstance has changed to make this application different from the previous ones. The only thing that has changed is the timing of the application; it is still the same ill health”. 

After joining issues, the judge adjourned to today for the parties to address the court on points of law.

At the resumed sitting, Etiaba, referred to paragraph 8 of the counter affidavit as “incompetent” and faulted some other paragraphs, insisting that the deponent did not disclose his source of information.

His words: “Our complaint against the paragraph goes to the substance of the depositions and not to the form as the prosecutor posited.

“What it all means is that Section 113 of the Evidence Act cannot be held to the complainant.

“Those paragraphs must be discountenanced on the second point that Exhibit 3 is a documentary hear-say and that it stands on nothing”. 

Etiaba also told the court that the ‘Exhibit 3’ disclosed one Dr. Raymond Onwuelo as the one who made the reference stressing that the materials employed by the maker of ‘Exhibit 3’ were disclosed as neurosurgical report from Nigeria.

He further argued that it was wrong for the prosecution to say that ‘Exhibit 3’ stands on nothing and that it is a documentary hear-say.

The learned silk referred the court to the case of Buhari versus Obasanjo 2015, 13 Nigeria Weekly Law Report, Part 941, page 317 and submitted the “exhibit 3 does not qualify as a documentary hear-say”.

He also told the court that the prosecution was invited by Metuh to come up with its medical team, to ascertain whether there is falsehood in the materials presented before the court.

He submitted that “having failed to produce medical team to ascertain the health condition of the first defendant (Metuh), the prosecution should be stopped from raising issues relating to whether the first defendant is ill or not”.

Tochuckwu Onwugbufor, SAN, counsel to the second defendant (Destra Investment Limited), also aligned himself with the arguments and submission of Etiaba.

Responding, Tahir vehemently disagreed with the arguments canvassed by the defence, using literal example to drive home his point.

“Let us put it in this context. In oral hearsay evidence, Mr. A tells somebody what Mr. C told him and the original person is not called to say by himself what he knows; that is oral hearsay”, Tahir said.

He continued by telling the court that with respect to ‘Exhibit 3’, the author of document referred to two reports: “One issued in January 2017 and the other, on January 30, 2018 by one Dr. Raymond Onwuelo”.

According to him, what Exhibit 3 was referring to was “a documentary hearsay. Them-say, them-say. What are they saying?”, Tahir queried.

He urged the court to hold that ‘Exhibit 3’ was a ‘documentary hearsay’.

After listening to arguments of both counsels, Justice Abang asked parties to submit all authorities cited to the court before the close of work today or before noon on Friday.

The judge added that upon the receipt of the authorities, the court will determine the date for ruling on the application.
Adeola Fayehun
Name

5 Minutes Interview With Our Young Entrepreneurs,2,Aba,1,Abia State,10,Abuja,18,Abuse,5,Accident,17,Accra,1,ACF,1,Actors,17,Actress,62,Adamawa State,4,Afghanistan,5,Africa,59,Agriculture,5,Air Force,2,Airways,5,AIT,1,Akwa-Ibom State,9,Algeria,4,Algiers,1,Amnesty International,1,Anambra State,45,Animal,6,APC,72,APGA,4,Arab,2,Argentina,4,Arizona,1,Army,10,Arsenal,18,Artist,1,Asaba,1,Asia,16,Assassination,1,Assault,5,Astronaut,1,Athletes,1,Atletico Madrid,1,Attack,2,AU,2,Australia,1,Authors,7,Automobile,6,Awards,44,Babies,2,Bangladeshi,3,Barcelona,5,Bayelsa State,11,BB Africa,1,BB Naija,46,Beauty Contest,1,Beirut,1,Benue State,30,Biafra,35,Birth,7,Birthday,24,Bitcoins,1,Boat,1,Boko Haram,19,Borno State,14,Botswana,3,Boxing,7,Boys Scout,1,Brazil,8,Britain,3,Business,87,BVN,1,Calabar,4,California,3,Cameroon,4,Campus,4,CAN,4,Canada,14,Careers,15,Carnival,1,Catalonia,3,CBN,7,CCIS,1,Celebrations,107,Celebrities,494,celebrity,1,Central Africa,1,Ceremonies,1,Chad,1,Champions League,1,Charity,1,Chelsea,7,Chicago,1,Child Abuse,10,Children,4,China,21,Christianity,109,Christmas,8,CIA,1,CID,1,Climate,1,Clubs,1,Columbia,1,Comedians,2,Comedy,2,Commonwealth,2,Congo,3,Corruption,76,Cote D’Ivoire,2,Couples,72,Crime,253,Crisis,1,Cross-River State,11,Cultism,9,Culture,1,Custom,6,Cutist,1,Cyprus,1,Dancers,1,Dapchi,1,Death,148,Dedication,1,Delta State,8,Democratic Republic Of Congo,1,Dinner,1,Discover,4,Divorce,6,Dog,1,Donald Trump,1,Dortmund,1,Drugs,2,DSS,4,Dubai,4,Eathquakes,2,Ebola,1,Ebonyi State,9,Economy,58,ECOWAS,3,Edo State,14,Education,82,EFCC,50,Egypt,15,Ekiti State,12,Election,102,Electricity,3,Empowerment,1,England,9,English,1,Entertainment,381,Entrepreneurs,1,Enugu State,14,Enyimba,1,EPL,4,Erosion,1,Ethiopia,6,Europa League,1,Europe,10,European Union,3,Events,11,Everton,1,Exam Malpractice,5,Facebook,70,Fact,1,Families,69,Fashion,26,FBI,2,FC Cologne,1,FCT,4,Festivals,6,FG,14,FIFA,4,Finance,23,Fire,11,Flight,15,Florida,2,Football,79,Football transfer,1,Foreign,376,France,10,Frankfurt,1,Fraud,10,Freedom,1,French,1,Fuel,10,Fulani,15,Gabon,1,Gadgets,5,Gambia,2,Gambling,1,Games,1,Gay,1,Gaza,4,Germany,9,Ghana,41,Girls Scout,1,Gist,1,Gombe State,3,Google,1,government,2,Governor,3,Grammy,1,Guest Post,9,Hackers,1,Haiti,1,Halloween,6,Harare,2,Harmattan,1,Headies,1,Health,72,Herat,1,Herdsmen,2,Hilarious,109,History,1,Holidays,1,Hollywood,5,Hospitals,1,House Of Assembly,3,House Of Reps,8,Houthis,1,Human Rights,6,Hungary,3,Ibadan,2,Igbo,3,Ijaw,1,Ikeja,1,Illuminati,1,Immigration,3,Imo State,54,IMSU,14,India,16,Indianapolis,1,Indonesia,2,INEC,7,Inspirational,11,Instagram,128,Internet,9,INTERPOL,1,Interview,23,Inventions,1,INYC,1,iPhone,1,IPOB,21,Iran,13,Iraq,4,Ireland,1,ISIS,6,Islam,37,Israel,21,Issues,1058,Istanbul,1,Italy,9,Itsekiri,1,JAMB,6,Japan,3,Jerusalem,4,Jews,2,Jobs,4,Jos,1,Journalist,1,Judaism,2,Kaduna State,13,Kano State,6,Kashmir,2,Kastina State,5,Kebbi State,6,Kenya,17,Kidnap,32,Kitchen,1,Kogi State,9,Kumawood,1,Kuwait,2,Kwara State,4,La Liga,2,Ladies,1,Lagoon,3,Lagos State,136,Lebanon,5,Legal,134,Lekki,1,Lesbian,3,Liberia,12,Libya,23,Lifestyle,61,Lisbon,1,Liverpool,2,Local,502,London,6,Los Angeles,2,LUTH,1,Madrid,1,Maiduguri,2,Makurdi,1,Malaria,1,Malaysia,4,Manchester City,1,Manchester United,9,Manila,1,Marriage,5,MASSOB,1,Mauritian,1,Media,10,Mediterranean Sea,3,Men,1,Mexico,3,Miami,1,Michigan,1,Microsoft,1,Middle East,22,Militant,7,Military,53,Mississippi,1,MMM,1,Model,3,Modelling,2,Morocco,3,Moscow,3,Movies,6,Murder,7,Music,188,Musician,121,NAFDAC,3,Nairobi,1,NASA,1,Nasarawa State,2,Nature,4,NBC,1,NCAA,2,NDDC,1,NDLEA,1,NECO,1,Netherlands,1,New Delhi,2,New Music,48,New York,5,News,2094,NFF,1,Niger,2,Niger Delta,4,Niger Delta Avengers,2,Niger State,8,Nigeria,890,Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps,6,Nigerian Army,8,NNPC,9,Nollywood,47,North America,3,North Carolina,1,North Korea,5,Northern Ireland,1,NOUN,1,NSCDC,1,NTA,1,NUC,1,NURTW,1,Nutrition,4,NYSC,8,Oakland,1,OAU,1,Ogun State,6,Ohio,3,Oil,4,Oklahoma,1,Omoku,2,Ondo State,19,Onitsha,1,Ontario,1,Opinions,21,Oscars,1,Osogbo,1,Osun State,10,Ottawa,1,Owerri,20,Oyo State,6,Pakistan,5,Palestine,11,Panama,1,Paris,2,PDP,49,Pension,1,Petroleum,12,Philippines,4,Photography,4,Photos,451,Pinterest,2,Plane Crash,1,Plateau State,8,Plateau United,1,Poland,1,Police,92,Politician,188,Politics,542,Port-Harcourt,7,Portland,1,Portugal,1,Premier League,1,Presidency,42,Prison,25,Prison Break,4,Prisoner,15,Prostitution,2,Qatar,7,Quotes,1,Racism,2,Rape,28,Real Madrid,5,Reality TV,39,Relationship,111,Religion,160,Reports,1,Rivers State,31,Robbery,13,Rohingya,1,Roma,1,Romance,7,Romania,1,Rome,3,Royal,15,RSS,1,Russia,29,Rwanda,1,Rwandan,1,Sacramento,1,Samsung,1,SARS,24,Satanism,3,Saudi Arabia,18,Scam,2,Scammers,1,Scandals,2,Science,2,Scientists,1,SDP,1,Security,7,Seminars,1,Senate,42,Senator,20,Senegal,3,Seoul,1,Sex,3,Showbiz,48,Sierra Leone,1,Slavery,12,Smuggling,4,Snakes,1,Snapchat,15,Social Media,326,Sokoto State,3,Somalia,6,SON,1,South Africa,35,South Carolina,1,South Korea,5,South Sudan,1,Space,2,Spain,7,Sponsored,11,Sports,114,Spotlight,1,Strike,1,Stroke City,1,Students,4,Suicide,19,Super Eagles,3,Swaziland,1,Sweden,1,Swiss,1,Syria,29,Taiwan,1,Taliban,1,Tanzania,5,Taraba State,2,Tax,1,Technology,1,Teens,6,Tegucigalpa,1,Tennis,1,Terrorism,41,TESS,1,Texas,2,Thailand,4,Theft,2,Togo,4,Tokyo,1,Toronto,1,Tottenham,1,Trafficking,2,Travel,3,Turkey,8,Twins,5,Twitter,121,U.S.A,188,UAE,7,UEFA,1,Uganda,6,UK,39,Ukraine,2,UN,13,UNESCO,1,UNICEF,1,UNILAG,1,United Arab Emirates,3,United States of America,3,UNJSPF,1,UNN,1,UPP,1,USA,5,Uyo,1,Vacations,1,Vactican City,2,Vatican,1,Venezuela,2,Victory,1,Video,144,Violence,2,Viral pictures & Videos,1,VISA,1,WAEC,3,Washington,1,Water,5,Weapons,1,Weather,2,Wedding,43,Weekend,2,West Africa,5,West Brom,1,WhatsApp,5,WHO,6,Wildlife,1,Women,26,World Bank,2,World Cup,2,World Richest men,1,Writers,3,Yemen,3,Yenagoa,1,Yobe State,2,Yoruba,2,Youths,1,YouTube,56,Zambia,4,Zimbabwe,37,
ltr
item
Reporter 247: Alleged N400m fraud: Court gives condition for granting Olisa Metuh’s application to travel for medicals
Alleged N400m fraud: Court gives condition for granting Olisa Metuh’s application to travel for medicals
Justice Okon Abang of the Federal High court sitting in Maitama, Abuja, on Thursday, March 15, 2018, gave...
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-WhYdQ3SxOfA/WqsyS4H5J6I/AAAAAAAAfJQ/UIs78ZIwp30VwJlweG1oYgK9lZvY6YfgACLcBGAs/s640/DYWTc2KVQAAb6lM.jpg
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-WhYdQ3SxOfA/WqsyS4H5J6I/AAAAAAAAfJQ/UIs78ZIwp30VwJlweG1oYgK9lZvY6YfgACLcBGAs/s72-c/DYWTc2KVQAAb6lM.jpg
Reporter 247
http://www.reporter247.org/2018/03/alleged-n400m-fraud-court-gives.html
http://www.reporter247.org/
http://www.reporter247.org/
http://www.reporter247.org/2018/03/alleged-n400m-fraud-court-gives.html
true
5246412718434376728
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy